Finding Your Perfect Match: How to Choose the Right Book Editor

You’ve poured your heart and countless hours into writing your manuscript. The finish line is in sight—but before you can hold your book in your hands, there’s one crucial step left: editing. Finding the right editor can make all the difference in transforming your draft into a polished, publish-ready book. But how do you know who’s the right fit for you and your story?

Here are a few key steps to help you choose wisely.

1. Request a Sample Edit

Most professional editors offer a sample edit on a few pages of your manuscript. This is more than just a courtesy—it’s an essential way to see how an editor works with your writing. Do they catch the issues you worry about? Do their suggestions feel constructive, or do they change your voice in ways that don’t feel right? A sample edit lets you test the waters before diving into a full collaboration.

2. Ask for Their Portfolio

Just like you’d want to know a builder’s past projects before trusting them with your dream home, you should know what an editor has worked on before. Ask for examples of books, articles, or journals they’ve edited. Reading published works they’ve touched can give you a sense of their experience, strengths, and editing style.

3. Understand Their Communication Style

Editing is more than just fixing commas—it’s a partnership. Some editors provide detailed explanations for every suggested change, while others keep feedback brief and to the point. Think about what you need as a writer. Do you prefer lots of dialogue and encouragement, or do you like straight-to-the-point corrections? Finding an editor whose communication style matches your needs will make the process smoother—and far more enjoyable.

4. Clarify Their Services

Editing isn’t one-size-fits-all. Developmental editing, line editing, copyediting, and proofreading each serve different purposes. Make sure you understand what type of editing you need at this stage, and confirm that the editor you’re considering offers that service. The best editor for you is one who meets you exactly where you are in your writing journey.

Final Thoughts

Choosing an editor is a deeply personal decision—after all, this is the person you’ll trust with your creative vision. Take the time to explore your options, ask questions, and trust your instincts. With the right editor by your side, you’ll not only strengthen your manuscript—you’ll grow as a writer.

At Regan Edits, I believe editing is a partnership built on trust, respect, and a shared goal: making your book the best it can be.

👉 Ready to take the next step? Contact me today to request a free sample edit or schedule a consultation. Let’s talk about your book, your goals, and how I can help you bring your manuscript to its fullest potential.